Butter, flour, sugar and eggs form a versatile foundation. We start with the basics and get wacky (or traditional) with sweetness. Our cookies range from Old-fashioned Drop Cookies (like Snickerdoodles) to Buttery Shortbread to Coconut Haystacks. Grab an assortment to make your crowd smile!
One "Toff" Cookie $ 2.50
Salty Toffee with Dark Chocolate
Cinnamon Snick $ 2.50
Classic Snickerdoodle featuring Vanilla and, of course... Cinnamon
Blackstrap Betty $ 2.50
Chewy Molasses Drop Cookie with Chunks of Dried Apricots
Classic 2-Tone $ 2.50
Old-School Drop Cookie with Milk and Dark Chocolate Chunks
Oat Cranberry $ 2.50
Oat Drop Cookie with Brown Sugar and Cranberries
The Yeti $ 2.50
Dark Chocolate Drop Cookie with Sweet Coconut and White Chocolate Chunks
Pucker Up $ 2.50
Our Tangy Lemon Sugar Cookie, the name says it all
Burnin' Love $ 2.50
Dark Chocolate Cookie with Chocolate Chunks, Cinnamon, and Chipotle Powder
Flourless Walnut Mudslide $ 1.50
Fudgy, Rich Chocolate Walnut Drop Cookie - Contains No Flour
Coconut Haystacks $ 1.50
Our Take on Classic Coconut Macaroons - Contains No Flour
Drop Cookies Sold Individually
Caspian Teas $ 3.75
Crisp Shortbread with Pistachios, Walnuts, Cardamom and Cinnamon - Pack of 8
Cranberry Shorties $ 3.75
Crisp Shortbread with Tangy Cranberries - Pack of 8
Mocha Walnut Shorties $ 3.75
Crispy morsels of Bittersweet Cocoa, Coffee, and Crunchy Walnuts that explode with Flavor - Pack of 8
Pecan Zesties $ 3.75
Our Classic Vanilla Shortbread with Pecans, Whole Wheat Flour and Orange Zest - Pack of 8
Brown Butter Cocoa Nib Shorties $ 3.75
Browned Butter and Crispy Cocoa Nibs combine to make these Shortbread irresistible - Pack of 8
Poppy Earl Grey Shorties $ 3.75
Perfect for Tea, these Shortbread contain Poppy Seeds, Earl Grey and Citrus Zest - Pack of 8
Medium Shortbread Cookie Assortment $11.00
Try all of our Various Shortbread - 3 each of Caspian Teas, Cranberry Shorties, Mocha Walnut Shorties, Pecan Zesties, Poppy Earl Grey Shorties and Brown Butter Nib Shorties
Decorated Shortbread $ 3.50
Butter, Flour, and Sugar baked tender and crisp hand-decorated with colorful Royal Icing - Pack of 1 or 2
Blackmarket Bar $ 2.75
Our Signature - Oat Streusel topping Apricots, Chocolate and Caramel on Shortbread
Florentine $ 2.75
Sliced Almonds, Cranberries and Candied Ginger in our Honey Caramel on Shortbread
PB Blondie $ 2.75
Our House-made Peanut Butter with Chopped Salted Peanuts & Dark Chocolate
Triple Shot Brownie $ 2.75
Chocolate Overload with our Rich Brownie with Dark Cocoa Powder and Dark Chocolate Chunks, Topped with Chocolate Ganache
Peanut Butter Sandwich $ 2.50
Peanut-laden, Slightly Crispy yet Chewy Cookies, sandwiching Chocolate Peanut Butter Filling
Russian Tea Cookies $ 4.50
Melt-in-your-mouth Walnut Cookies rolled in Snowy Powdered Sugar (9 Per Box)
Flourless Almond Brownie Bites $ 5.75
Almond provide the structure in these fudge-y nuggets of joy. (6 Per Box)